People left 'in limbo' after pause to gender-affirming surgery in Wales, Llais report finds
People affected by the pause to gender-affirming surgery in Wales have described severe distress, worsening mental health and months of uncertainty about their future care, in a new report published today by Llais.
The report, What we are hearing: the pause to gender-affirming surgery, is based on evidence gathered from people directly affected by the pause, representative organisations supporting trans and non-binary people, and discussions with the NHS Wales Joint Commissioning Committee (NWJCC).
In late August 2026, the NWJCC paused new referrals for gender-affirming surgery, surgical assessments and scheduled operations while an independent clinical review of the surgical referral pathway takes place. Cardiff and Vale University Health Board, which hosts the Welsh Gender Service, subsequently wrote to 451 people on the surgical pathway. Around 60 people due to undergo surgery before the end of December are being reviewed first, meaning most people do not yet know when their cases will be considered.
Many people who contacted Llais have said they still do not know when their own case will be considered or what the outcome may mean for them.
Impact on people’s lives
Over a three-month period, Llais heard from people who described the significant impacts on the wellbeing and daily lives caused by the pause.
People told Llais they had experienced:
- Severe distress and worsening mental health.
- Uncertainty about their future treatment.
- Difficulties planning work, study, finances and family life.
- Financial losses linked to postponed surgery.
- Confusion about the review process and what it means for them.
Some people also told the citizen voice body that surgeries were cancelled only days, and in some cases hours, before they were due to take place. Others said the first they learned about the pause was through social media rather than directly from the NHS.
One person affected by the pause told Llais:
"I have been waiting over ten years for surgery and it's left me feeling so hopeless."
Others told Llais they felt they had been left "in limbo". Some people also questioned why they were being reassessed after already completing a lengthy clinical pathway and expressed concerns about the purpose of some of the review questions that are being asked.
Representative organisations also raised concerns about whether sufficient proactive emotional and psychological support is available for people affected by the pause, as well as for their families and carers.
Concerns about communication and decision-making
The report highlights concerns raised by people about how decisions affecting their care were communicated and the extent to which people using services were involved.
People told Llais they wanted clearer information about:
- Why the pause was introduced.
- What the review process involves.
- When their individual case is likely to be considered.
- What decisions could be made as a result of the review.
Llais also raises concerns about the process used to make and implement the decision to pause gender-affirming surgery.
Llais believes that decisions with significant implications for people using services should be informed by an assessment of the impact on those affected alongside clinical considerations. This should include evidence from patient feedback, complaints, correspondence and other relevant sources of insight.
The report concludes that these considerations should help inform decisions before they are taken, rather than being assessed after implementation.
Llais's position is that Welsh Government guidance on service change should have been followed when the decision to pause gender-affirming surgery was made.
Calls to the NWJCC
The report calls on the NWJCC to make sure there is:
- Greater transparency about the pause, the clinical review and future decisions affecting the service.
- Clear information for people affected about where they stand, when their case will be reviewed and what happens next.
- Appropriate emotional and psychological support while people wait.
- Accessible reviews, including support for neurodivergent people and others who may need reasonable adjustments.
- Meaningful involvement of people with lived experience in shaping the future of gender services in Wales.
Ben Eaton, Executive Director of Planning and Delivery and Deputy Chief Executive at Llais, said:
"The strongest message we heard was about the impact this has had on people's mental health and wellbeing.
"People spoke about severe distress, uncertainty and feeling unable to plan for the future while they wait to learn what happens next.
"Some of the people most directly affected may still be waiting for information about their own situation. People should not be left relying on public announcements to understand what is happening with their care.
"In our new report we have set out practical steps that people told us would provide greater certainty, support and involvement in decisions affecting their care.
"Everyone who uses health and care services in Wales has the right to be heard. That principle applies here just as it does in every other part of the NHS."
Has your care been affected?
If you have been affected by the pause to gender-affirming surgery referrals or procedures, we want to hear from you.
You can tell us about your experience by completing our national survey, or by speaking directly with a member of your local Llais team. Whatever you choose, we're here to listen.
Share your story online or contact your Llais local team to speak to a member of staff.
The Welsh Gender Service is publishing updates and answers to frequently asked questions on its website, available here.